Open-ear vs. in-ear headphones: Your perfect fit awaits

Woman wearing Bose Ultra Open Earbuds

How, when, and where you listen to music, podcasts, or audiobooks will all influence your choice between open-ear vs. in-ear headphones. Open-ear headphones are attached to the outside of the ear and project audio without any direct contact with the ear canal. In-ear headphones, or earbuds, have soft tips that seal the ear canal, with the sound funneled directly to your eardrums. Over-ear headphones are a third option; they typically have a headband and cover the ears completely. Here's what you need to know to find your perfect fit.

Key questions to ask yourself

If you’re in the market for headphones, ask yourself these questions to help you weigh the pros and cons of over-ear vs. open-ear vs. in-ear headphones. Depending on your answers, you may be firmly in the “focus and immersion” camp or the “freedom and awareness” camp.

Do you want to block out external noise?

Do you want the spatial audio experience?

Do you need to focus on work and keep out external distractions?

Do you prefer wearing headphones that seal the ear canal, or leave it open?

Do you need to always be aware of your surroundings?

Are you usually stationary or moving when you listen to music?

Do you change tasks frequently and need to talk to others often?

Do you like to wear headphones all day, or do you listen in short, concentrated bursts?

Is it important that other people aren’t disturbed by your listening?

What’s most important to you: focus and immersion, freedom and awareness, or comfort and fit?

Focus and immersion

If you depend on headphones to be productive at work, focus and immersion is an important element. Here’s what each headphone type provides in this area.

Open ear

Open-ear headphones have their benefits, but focus and immersion is not one of them. You'll hear more of the outside world with open-ear headphones. The spatial audio does provide some sense of immersion, but it won't be the same as using in-ear or over-ear headphones with noise cancellation.

In ear

In-ear headphones like Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds create a seal at the entrance to your ear canal. This makes it possible to block external sounds very effectively, and when you add in active noise cancellation, you can enjoy your favourite audio with no distractions. In-ear headphones are a great choice if you want to tune out the outside world and create a private, personal space to enjoy your audio content, anytime and anywhere.

The active noise cancellation can be easily customized to your preferred level using the Bose Music app. With a quick tap in the app, you can switch from the full immersion of Quiet Mode to Aware Mode, so you can hear ambient noise as well. This is great if you take a break from studying to go grab a quick coffee. Controlling the level of sound that comes through from your surroundings gives you the flexibility to enjoy blissful peace and quiet, or take the edge off a noisy environment while still being able to recognize what's happening around you.

In-ear headphones are perfect if you work in a busy open-plan office or studio but still need to concentrate and do deep work without distractions from your colleagues and surroundings. They also help reduce the noise you create. It works both ways. Need to listen late at night, or in a busy area where it might be distracting for others to hear your music? In-ear headphones have great noise isolation, so you won't hear anyone else and they won't hear you.

Over ear

Over-ear headphones like the Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones offer an even greater sense of immersion and also feature active noise cancellation. They're comfortable and easy to wear for long periods, making them a good alternative to in-ear headphones if you want the same or better immersive qualities but don't like the sensation of having eartips inserted.

In a noisy neighborhood or apartment building, noise cancelling over-ear headphones can be a lifesaver, allowing you to carve out some personal time and isolation from daily distractions like traffic noise, loud neighbors, or barking dogs. Over-ear headphones are also perfect for daily commuting if you're traveling to the office and want to make the trip more enjoyable.

Freedom and awareness

Awareness when listening to headphones can offer you the freedom to go where you want safely and chat with people without having to hit pause on your favourite song.

Open ear

What are the benefits of open earbuds? Open-ear headphones like Bose Ultra Open Earbuds are the best option for people who need to be aware of their surroundings at all times. By attaching to the outer ear and not blocking the ear canal, open-ear headphones can give you the best of both worlds. You can take your music everywhere while staying conscious of what’s happening around you.

This is perfect in situations where you want to listen to music and socialize, like at a skate park. Open-ear headphones can provide a soundtrack as you skate, but you won't have to constantly pause to chat with your buddies. Plus, they'll stay put as you practice your kickflip.

Bose Ultra Open Earbuds are designed to be truly wearable, so you never have to worry about taking them off.

Open-ear headphones could have some sound leakage at maximum volume due to the fact they aren't inserted into the ear canal, so if you're in a quiet environment where you don't want to disturb others, over-ear headphones may be a better option.

In ear

Setting your in-ear headphones to Aware Mode lets the world back in, so you can hear what’s happening around you. Freedom is a good benefit of in-ear headphones, as they’re lightweight, comfortable, and easy to wear while you’re working, exercising, relaxing, or traveling.

Over ear

Over-ear headphones have the highest degree of natural noise reduction due to the way they cover the entire ear, and the active noise cancellation adds to the degree of sound isolation and immersion. While they also feature Aware Mode, if you really need to be alert and aware of your surroundings, in-ear or open-ear headphones are a better choice.

Other considerations when shopping for headphones

Here are other factors to consider when shopping for your perfect headphone fit.

Three takes on spatial audio

How does the sound quality compare between open-ear vs. in-ear headphones, or with over-ear headphones? In-ear and over-ear headphones generally have a deeper bass response than open-ear headphones. The sound of spatial audio from in-ear and over-ear headphones is rich and immersive, and sounds like it's coming from in front of you. These types of headphones also measure and adapt to your specific ear profile to ensure you're always experiencing sound that's perfectly customized to your individual hearing.

Open-ear headphones also feature great sound quality, but it’s a slightly different experience. Bose Ultra Open Earbuds combine spatial audio with head tracking to give you an unparalleled sense of open, airy sound that moves with you. They also automatically adjust their volume against environmental noise, so as your surroundings become noisier, the volume increases to compensate.

Comfort and fit

Some people like the snug fit and feel of in-ear headphones, or the enclosed, cushioned feel of over-ear headphones. Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds come with three different sizes of eartips and stability bands to ensure you can achieve the perfect fit for your ears. Once you find the right fit, they’ll stay in place effortlessly, and before you know it, you’ll forget you’re wearing them as the immersive sound takes over. The soft eartips and stability bands are designed to be comfortable for extended listening.

Bose QuietComfort Ultra over-ear Headphones have soft earcups and headband padding that keeps them firmly in position, but they are also very comfortable and suitable for all-day wear. You can learn more in our comparison guide for discovering which you prefer, earbuds vs. headphones.

Open-ear headphones have a lighter touch and space for air to circulate freely. Open-ear headphones are designed to be wearable all day, in any situation, and there’s no need to remove them even if you’re not actively listening to anything. They’re so comfortable once fitted, you’ll be free to experience their natural, open sound anytime you choose.

Versatility

To sum up, what are the benefits of open earbuds as opposed to in-ear earbuds, or over-ear headphones? It really comes down to how much of the surrounding world you want to let in. If you like to be able to hear your surroundings at all times while also listening to your favourite music, then open-ear headphones will probably be the best fit for you.

On the other hand, if you want some personal space and prefer being able to shut out the sounds of the external world, then in-ear or over-ear headphones are definitely the way to go. For true immersion mode and the highest degree of sound cancellation, over-ear headphones are the best choice. Whichever you choose, you’re sure to get more enjoyment from your day with the right audio accompaniment.

Finally, if you lead a varied lifestyle with a mix of all the scenarios we’ve examined here, there’s no reason you can’t use more than one type of headphones and switch between them whenever it suits you. However and wherever you like to enjoy your audio, Bose has you covered.

Featured in this story

Bose Ultra Open Earbuds tdt
Bose Ultra Open Earbuds
$379.00
2 Colours
2 Colours
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds tdt
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds
$379.00
3 Colours
3 Colours
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones tdt
Bose QuietComfort Ultra Headphones
$549.00
3 Colours
3 Colours